As of now, with the lone exception of Michael Clayton (which no one really predicted would win anything anyway) I have seen four out of five of the best picture nominees this year. It's a personal best for me since in the past I have seen two or maybe three. This year three films wowed me and made me think "oh yeah, they deserve to be nominated." And then there's "Atonement."
Every few years or so the academy gets some weird bug up its behind and nominates an extremely ordinary film as one of the best of the year. It happened with "Ghost," it happened with "Chocolat" and it's happened again here.
Although the film is being marketed as one of those great love stories to entice women into thinking they're going to see "Sense and Sensibility Part Deux", it's not really a love story at all.
It's more about betrayal.
All the time I was watching it, I kept wondering what the big deal was.
Kiera Knightly pouts, James Mcavoy shows restrained passion.
They make love on the lawn, then they do it in the library, and that's pretty much all you see before a little girl's lies tear them apart. Then James Mcavoy shows restrained rage, they're torn asunder and that's pretty much it.
To be fair, there are a few twists and turns as we see the ramifications of that lie and eventually we see her complicated attempts to make peace, but it's not particularly moving or special in any way. And once you've seen Kiera Knightly in that green dress, the film really doesn't have much else to offer.
Atonement: C
